ICT R&D Grants Programme for Asia Pacific
Project Title:
Leveraging Information Communication Technologies (ICTs) Through Weekly Market Centres for Tribal (Indigenous) Communities
|
1) Background Approximately 10,000 people from about 60 nearby villages gather for the weekly market every Monday, to purchase their essentials, sell their produce, carry out their bank operations, meet each other etc. Another 5000 visit it every Tuesday for the weekly cattle market. During the rest of the week, another 3000 to 5000 people visit Sawalmendha. Teenagers from nearby villages come there daily to attend high school and higher secondary school. Villagers thus cater to most of their day-to-day needs through the Weekly Market places. They however face problems in dealing with government, markets, health-care and education systems as also other elements of the larger world. The project's developmental objectives were to:
2) Synthesis : The objectives of the project were: The modus operandi of the project was:
Various activities done were: The computers and other instruments were operated/tested in harsh rural conditions. There was no significant breakdown throughout the project period. A network of Saathins (village information leaders) was established to work as catalysts. Generation of the requests for help was done through various means such as Saathins, SIRDI staff, by meeting people in the weekly market, conducting village level meetings etc. After months of follow-up with the telecom department internet connectivity was established at Sawalmendha.
Various activities like Agricultural Camp for farmers, Quiz Competition for students, Eye Camp for visually impaired people were carried out to reach more and more people and provide them benefits of the projects. The facilities like photocopy and lamination, students' results on internet were provided by the project at low cost. This saved a lot of time and money of the people and students. The project was successful in meeting its objectives in many ways as outlined :
3) Research Problem a) Technical
b) Social
4) Research Findings a) Technical This project was successful in bringing ICT to remote communities. But due to lack of awareness about ICT on the part of people in the project region the community could not really benefit through this on large basis in such a short period. Computers and other instruments were tested in real harsh conditions and did not give any major breakdown throughout the project period as proper care was taken in planning. Telephone lines being unreliable, the internet access was very difficult and it took months of perseverance to get the connection activated. The telecom milestones are attached at Annexure -4B. The literacy rate in the project region and awareness about ICT in the project region was almost negligible. b) Social The area where the project was carried out covered 68 villages. The response from the villages regarding the generation of requests for help was much healthier in those villages where SIRDI had already been working and was having its Social Workers based in those villages. As regards to the use of facilities provided by the ICT Project at Sawalmendha it was found that the literate people were keener to use the facilities. On the later stages of the project the local youth started taking keen interest in the activities of the centre and also showed keen interest in learning internet technology. The percentage of requests for help submitted by women remained consistent throughout the project period i.e. 35 %. Category wise chart of the requests for help submitted by people is attached at Annexure -6A to 6C . The flood of request, which initially was for seeking employment, got converted into information related and entrepreneurship sort when youth understood the rationale behind this project.
The developmental objectives of the project were : a) To leverage the Weekly Market Centre for fulfilling the needs of Tribal community- SIRDI established a Multi Facility Centre at the Weekly Market place Sawalmendha. This place is visited by thousands of villagers every week for purchasing their essentials and other routine work. By establishing this information centre with multile facilities SIRDI ICT project was able to fulfil many of the information needs of the villagers. b) To use Information and communications technology for fulfilling information needs of tribal community and understand the problem areas: § Examination Results on internet: The month of June here is the month of declaration of results for various examinations. For the first time in Sawalmendha and the nearby region the students were able to access their results SIRDI ICT centre at Sawalmendha on the same day the results were declared at minimum cost (a specimen copy of the mark sheet downloaded from the internet is attached at Annexure -12A). § Availability of government forms at Sawalmendha: As like the photocopy work people used to visit the Tehsil place Bhainsdehi or the District place Betul for collecting forms and pre-printed formats of the various certificates and forms needed for various purposes. SIRDI provided these forms at Sawalmendha ICT centre and saved time and money of the villagers on this front also. A sample of one of such forms is attached at Annexure - 12B. § Low cost photocopy and lamination facility: By installing a 4-in-1 machine (i.e. a machine with the printing, scanning, photocopying and fax facility) at Sawalmendha SIRDI provided a low cost photocopy solution to the people coming to the Weekly Market. This facility got an overwhelming response. People had to visit all the way to the Tehsil place Bhainsdehi for getting a single photocopy done. The economics of photocopying is attached at Annexure - 8A. d) To research the feasibility of using ICT in harsh Rural and Tribal environment 6) Project Design and Implementation The implementation part of the project had following key parts:
To setup the infrastructure : A place was hired in the market area, which could easily be sited by any visitor To develop suitable software: For entering the information requests of the villagers in the computer, special software was designed. The features of this specially designed software are described in Annexure -3A. All the inputs and outputs were in local language so that local people can access and understand it easily. To setup the Nodes: Besides the Sawalmendha Centre, nodes at Betul & Bhainsdehi were set up as part of the project to receive complaints or requests for help from the Sawalmendha Centre. After follow-up send back the info against the query to Sawalmendha For establishing the communication network between the villagers and the office at Sawalmendha: Two selected women from every village termed as "Saathins" (meaning companions) were given training for two days at the Sawalmendha ICT centre. A brief note on Saathins is attached as Annexure -5A. 7) Project Outputs & Dissemination As far as the output and the spread of the project is concerned there have been so many achievements for ICT Project in such a short span: The illiterate Tribal women who had never dreamt of Information Technology coming to their doorstep have been able to make use of ICT for their community benefit. The participation of women in the project in the form of Saathins (village information leaders) in the ICT project is a big achievement as far as Women's empowerment is concerned. We have also been able to form a federation of Saathins (Annexure -2). The money collected through photocopy, lamination charges and through charging for the students' results on internet is being deposited in a separate bank account for Saathins. This money will further be used for their benefit and for economic sustainability of the project. Out of the total number of requests generated women have given 35% of the requests. This itself is an indication that the project is pro -women and we have been successful in our efforts. A remote place like Sawalmendha which could not have otherwise got an access to ICT (though not as smooth and robust as city places) has now ICT facility. The young generation there can certainly benefit from it over the long run. Especially the girls who had difficulty in going to the Tehsil and District place for seeking smallest of information now access it easily. By installing a 4-in-1 machine (i.e. a machine with the printing, scanning, photocopying and fax facility) at Sawalmendha SIRDI has provided low cost photocopy solution to the people coming to Weekly Market and it is getting an overwhelming response. Through this SIRDI ICT project was able to save substantial time and money of the villagers. The month of June here is the month of declaration of results for various examinations. For the first time in Sawalmendha and the nearby region the students were able to access their results at SIRDI ICT centre on the same day the results were declared at minimum cost. Prior to this the cost incurred for this was huge as the students had to go to the District place Betul for availing this facility. The to and fro fare from Sawalmendha to Betul is Rs. 50 and it takes about 3 hours of hectic journey one-way. Plus the cyber café person at the District place charged a handsome amount for providing this facility. The initially required deliberate efforts for the generation of requests for help is not needed now as more and more people have become aware of the SIRDI's ICT centre and its activities. Out of the total requests generated for help we were able to forward most of requests relating to Agriculture, Education, Social Welfare Department, and Integrated Tribal Development Program (ITDP), which constitutes to a healthy percentage of the requests. Some sample requests for help under educational category, Bhola & Babita and under health category Seema & Jayna have been explained as illustrations. The details of these cases are briefed and attached at Annexure -7. Since the SIRDI team was able to convience the dignified cause of the project to the government the project certainly made the government authorities pro-active in supporting the project. The government took our assistance in carrying out various surveys. This in itself was an indication of the exactness of the data that we were able to generate through our software and the field team's penetration in the region. The Agriculture office has started sending an official every Monday to ICT Sawalmendha centre to solve queries of the villagers and to give them information about the latest schemes available with them. For the convenience of the villagers visiting the ICT centre at Sawalmendha the documents and forms for various government schemes were made available at through a compact disc. Also the manual copies of the same were made available at Sawalmendha ICT centre for the convenience of the people visiting Sawalmendha. So this became very convenient for the people, as this is the season when these forms are required in abundance. To create the awareness about the ICT Project and its objectives amongst youth in the project region, the project organized a "Quiz Competition " for the local youth, which got a very good response. Details of this are narrated at Annexure -9B. SIRDI ICT Project organized an eye camp to help out the people who are visually impaired .A total of 61 patients were checked and 10 of them were taken for operation to the hospital from the nearby region. A report on this is given at Annexure -9C. 8) Capacity Building The capacity building has two parts- Firstly, the active participation of the women in the project in the form of Saathins. The formation of Saathins' federation will certainly lead to building of self-esteem in the women. The money collected against the services provided is being deposited in a separate bank account for Saathins. This money will further be used for their benefit and for economic sustainability of the project. This gives them a kind of economic freedom, which they have been deprived of ages. It was one of the objectives of the project that the project should become economically viable over a period of time and should run through the women who have been trained under the project. However the initial period of one year proved to be very tight considering the low literacy rate and lack of awareness about ICT in the project region. Also the geographical location of the villages had its own effect on the speed of the project. When the project got its publicity in the region and some steps for revenue generation were taken, now there are a bundle of opportunities for sustaining this project further. To add to this SIRDI's own Self Help Groups started incorporating with the ICT and help women in developing as entrepreneurs. Efforts in this direction have already been started and Saathins federation has already been formed. What we were striving for is the economic independence for women, which will certainly lead to their confidence boosting and changing their overall vision and perception towards life. Once they are through this then they will certainly broaden their horizon and think beyond community, beyond village i. e. for their country. Secondly, capacity building of SIRDI's own team working on ICT Project, which played a key role in the accomplishment of this project. This project operated at four different locations Sawalmendha being at the core, SIRDI's headquarter Bahiram, the Tehsil place Bhainsdehi and District place Betul. In addition to this the consultants and advisors operated from distant places. So for keeping the co-ordination, the communication channels had to be excellent. So some off-bit channels of communications like sending floppies and CDs via drivers of local buses were discovered. The team members ultimately learned to develop their own work systems to get the things done under odd circumstances and achieve their goal. It was really tough for the team members to work at such a remote place where the communication means are not reliable; the power conditions are very poor, water supply is irregular, and living conditions are not so hygienic. This certainly added to their mental toughness and increased their capacity to work under harsh rural conditions. On technical fronts also this project has really taught us so many new things. Being at a remote place where the technical assistance was not available the team members had to upgrade their technical skills like networking, maintenance of the power back-up instruments, and also do the troubleshooting on their own. Interaction with the people from the project region was another front on which the team learnt a lot. People not being ready to open up easily made the ICT people test their patience. 9) Project Management There were noteworthy constraints in executing all the activities within a well-defined time frame. It was difficult task attend to all the details of implementation spread over 68 villages. Also the geographical remoteness of the villages had its own effects on the speed of the project. Administration by SIRDI: The project worked in an action research mode. SIRDI applied all its experience of almost 25 years in rural development for making this project a success with respect to the developmental objectives. Considering the short-term nature of the project SIRDI had to use all its contacts and good will to gear up the activities in the project. The management provided adequate care and support in terms of time and knowledge to implement the project. The following individuals provided useful professional inputs for the project: Dr. Upma Diwan - Handled total administration of the project. She led the project from the front and marshalled her resources to optimum levels. Other consultants and advisors adding value to the project by providing links, resources and ideas to the project: Dr. S. S. Chakravarty and Shekhar Borgaonkar, Shubhranshu Chowdhury, Guru Dutt and Yogesh Andlay, & Smt. Smita Chowdhary 10) Impact The impact of this project can be assessed at different levels: 1. ICT Awareness : First and foremost is the awareness of ICT and its usefulness for the people in this region. People have started feeling the need and realizing the significance of this kind of project, which can become a bridge between them and the government machinery. For example Students are finding it easy to seek out the information they regularly need as the ICT centre falls well within their reach. 2. This project has certainly made an impact on the local i.e. district level administration system. With the top level officials like the district collector, the CEOs of various departments taking the cognisance of the activities of the project there is a strong likehood that the project will make the flow of information between government & citizens easier. Also the visit of former Minister for Information Technology, Government of India (currently holding portfolio of Minister for Petroleum and Natural Gas ) Smt. Sumitra Mahajan to the ICT Centre at Sawalmendha , the project has certainly got a recognition not in this region but also in the state and has made a positive impact on the local and district level administration system which will help on the long run. A detail of her visit to ICT Centre Sawalmendha is attached at Annexure -9A. 3. Women Empowerment - Saathin Federation : 11) Overall assessment
12) Recommendations: We would like to make the following recommendations to Centre/IDRC/APCIP :
Annexures to Final Report 1. Annexure 1- Map of Betul District 2. Annexure 2 - Saathin Federation 3. Annexure 3 - Software § Annexure 3A - Software Features § Annexure 3B - English Translation of Request for Help Form
§ Annexure 4B - Telecom Milestones 5. Annexure 5- Gender Bias § Annexure 5A - A note on Saathins 6. Annexure 6- Requests for Help
7. Annexure 7- Case Studies § Bhola (Educational)
§ Annexure 8A -Mini-case about "The Economics of Photocopying & Lamination"
§ Annexure 9A - Smt. Sumitra Mahajan's (Former Minister of IT, Government of India) and currently Minister of State for Petroleum & Natural Gas) visit to ICT Centre Sawalmendha § Annexure 9B - Quiz Competition for youth § Annexure 9C - Eye Camp Report 10. Annexure 10 - Mechanisms for Generating Requests for Help 11. Annexure 11 - List of Photographs to this report
§ Annexure 12A - Examination Result from internet (a sample of marksheet) Annexure 1: Map of Betul District
Annexure 2: Saathin Federation
Who is a Saathin? § A Saathin is a member of Self-Help Group. The formal announcement for the federation of Saathins by SIRDI and SIRDI ICT Project took place on the eve of the "Yuva Shram Sadhak Samaj Function" on 25 May 2003. Annexure 3: Software for request for help Ø Annexure 3A:Software Features 1) Data Entry & Authorization: Ø Annexure 3 (B): English translation of request for help (Data Entry) form Satpura Integrated Rural Development Institution (SIRDI) ICT Project, Sawalmendha Form No…… Name of the Village................... Name of the Applicant............ Father's Name ………. Sex …………… Age ……………… Caste…………..(SC/ST/OBC/Others) Educational Qualification of Applicant................................ Applicant's Profession.................................. Yearly Income of the Applicant................................(Less than 5000/ between 5000 to 12000/between 12000 to 20000/Above 20000) Does applicant belong to any special category?.............................(Handicap/Widow/Divorcee/Others) Land Holding of the Applicant....................................( Less than 5 acres/between 5 to 10 acres/10 acres and above) What type of information does the applicant want?.............................(Job/Health/Education/Agriculture/Other) What is the present source of applicant for seeking this information?........................................ What is the approximate time involved in seeking this information? .................... What is the approximate expenditure involved in seeking this information? .................................... Name of the person who submitted the application .......................... His relationship with the applicant ( if any ) .............................. Detail explanation about the request (Use back page if required) ...................................... Annexure 4: Power and Telecom Logs
Ø Annexure 4 B: Telecom Milestones
Annexure 5:Gender Bias
In ICT Project an innovative concept of making village women participate in the community development was introduced. Those women were termed as Saathins (companions). Who is a Saathin? § A Saathin is a member of Self-Help Group.
S.N . Name Name of the Village
Saathin Training Batch III
Saathin Training Batch V (Organized on the occasion of International Women's Day 7th and 8th March 03) S.No. Name Village
Dates 02/04/03 to 03/04/03 S.No. Name Village
Ø Annexure 6 B: Occupational Categorisation of Requests for Help
Ø Annexure 6 C: Categorisation of Types of Requests for Help
Ø Annexure 6 D: Sample List of Requests
Ø A farmer with 2 acres barren land wanting to know how to take better yields. v Job Ø A graduate wanting help in searching a job. v Loan Ø An illiterate landless labourer aged 35 wanting loan for Goat farming. v Education & Training Ø An electrician who has done some preliminary training wanting to specialize. v Health Ø A 40 odd year old woman treated for skin ailment by a quack for 6 months, with no result, asking help. v Social Welfare Ø A lady aged 60+, with 2 children, wanting monthly pension from government. Ø Handicapped student wanting tricycle for coming to school. v Other Information Ø Villagers collectively asking for construction of road. Ø Girls from far off villages wanting admission to girls' hostel Ø A 20-year tractor driver wanting to get driving license. Ø A local entrepreneur asking for addresses of websites to search vendors for his products Annexure 7 : Case studies
Bhola is a thirteen-year-old boy from the village Junapani near Sawalmendha. The village has schooling facilities only up to 5th standard. After finishing his schooling in the village Bhola wanted to take admission in the high school at Sawalmendha. His parents are blind and hence unable to work and struggling to meet their both ends. So there was no question of them encouraging him for continuing his education.
Seema Patankar is a small girl aged 6 years. Her parents who are poor farmers were deeply worried. Seema is the eldest of their four children. She was growing by age but she did not have any hair on her head. Even her height was not increasing as per her age. Vastala, a Saathin from the village Themgaon (where Seema and her parents reside) submitted this request for help at ICT centre Sawalmendha. A renowned Homoeopath from Bhopal (the capital of Madhya Pradesh) was consulted regarding this problem. Seema was given medicine and started growing hair on her head with Homoeopathic Medicine. Her parents have reported a growth of half inch when ICT team visited her village for feedback. Her parents want to continue the same medicine for her now. Jayna is a young woman aged about 30 years. She had reported swelling and severe pain in her left foot. Jayna was also seeking help from local doctor but in vain. Saathin from her village Vastala submitted her request for help. ICT team visited her place and saw her condition. Immediately her case was referred to the renowned Homoeopath. Now SIRDI is providing her medical assistance.
Ø Annexure 8 A: Economics of photocopying Rajjo Bai from village Temni under the SIRDI ICT Project wanted to submit the photocopy of her Yearly Income Certificate to the Banker for procurement of some loan. There was no mode of transport from her village to the Sawalmendha Weekly Market. People travel the distance of about 10 km in the private tractors owned by the traders who carry people to Sawalmendha along with their produce. The charges are Rs. 10 for the round trip. When she reaches Bhainsdehi, she often faces power-cut/load-shedding. If this happens, she needs to come back on some other day, and if this happens the cost can double. Ø Annexure 8 B :Internet based examination results dissemination at ICT Sawalmendha (cost and time saving) When the results are declared the normal procedure here is that the results are out in the local and regional newspapers. The newspapers only declare the status of a student whether he is in pass or fail category. The mark sheets are then sent to the principals of respective schools. The process almost takes two to three weeks. Many of the villages where SIRDI ICT Project is working don't even have regular access to newspapers. So the only mode of getting results for the students is to visit the district place Betul or the nearby town in Maharashtra State Paratwada. To and fro expenses from the nearby villages to Betul or Paratwada range between Rs. 30 to 50. One-way journey is 3 hours to Betul. The cyber cafés in those places charge Rs. 20 for a duplicate mark sheet available on the internet. In case of power failure the students have to wait for hours for getting their work done. It adds to their expenses. On an average a student spends Rs.60 for getting his result. In the month of June ICT provided this facility at Rs. 10 per result to the students. Annexure 9: Meetings and Awareness Campaigns
Ø Annexure 9 B: A report on eye camp
Ø Annexure 9 C: Quiz Competition for the youth Every year SIRDI celebrates May 26th as "Youth Day". This year to create the awareness about ICT Project and its activities, a quiz competition was organized for the interested youth in the project area. The participants were divided into the groups of four each and given a questionnaire of hundred questions to solve. Twenty participants in five groups participated in the quiz. The winners were given books written by honorable President of India, Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam as prizes. Annexure 10: Mechanisms for Generating Requests for Help To reach large numbers of people for requests for help The ICT project team adopted various means. The predominant ones were: 1. Through Saathins Annexure 11: Photographs Ø Annexure 11 A: Photographs Up to Mid Term Report (January 2003)
Ø Annexure 11 B: Photographs after Mid Term Photo 1 Dr. Upma Diwan Addressing Saathins at Saathin Federation Meeting Annexure 12: Miscellaneous Ø Annexure 12 A: Examination Result (a sample of mark sheet)
|
|
Last modified 2004-06-15 03:01 PM










